Fic Rec, Will the Real Ichigo Please Stand Up?

[http://users.livejournal.com/_debbiechan_/]

 nehalenia  is one of those writers like incandescens or laurie_bunter--I'm just going to rec ALL this writer's Bleach fic anyway so just remember the author's name. She's done it again. This time she's written a piece that for being first person Hollow!Ichigo narration is surprisingly eloquent-- yet the guy is  IC. Hollow!Ichigo maintains a dynamic with an Ichigo who figures in the story even if nicey Ichigo's not there. The violence is handled expertly--it's never over the top. The characterizations make me give this piece of smut my "more than smut" award (didn't know I gave those out, eh? Usually sublimeparadigm racks them all up in my head for her emotional but hardcore yaoi stuffs). And yes, it's disturbing subject matter, and yes it's disturbingly erotic, and yes, the story is about that ambivalence. It's smart stuff.

Runaway Horse (NC17) by  nehalenia Warning: non-con, yaoi, Hollow Ichigo/Ishida

Now more about chapter 315. The scans are out, and I've read at least two interesting discussions on friends' LJs about Ichigo's character--is it consistent? What about his speech to Kenpachi at the end of the chapter? IC? Unnecessary?

I loved the whole chapter--the art was spectacular, the return of Ulquiorra gave me goosebumps and the eyeball exchanges between Ulqui and Orihime were ZOWIE! off the charts. (Does Kubo even know what sort of UST he's created here? I suspect he does. Last year's Hime slap on Valentine's day seemed like pure calculated romance to me. In the cleverest, most demented sort of Kubo way, of course).

The only criticisms I've been hearing about the chapter concern Ichigo.  Why is he being so spastic? turkwriter explained it all very neatly by reminding me that Ichigo is SIXTEEN. That explains the spazzing, but what about the righteous speech towards Kenpachi?I thought that Ichigo's whole panicking to save Karakura and then rushing to fight Ulquiorra once he detected the Espada's presence was very much in character. What some people are questioning was Ichigo's taking the time to make the little speech--"You're wrong, Kenpachi." Kenpachi was wrong? What?

Of course Kenpachi wasn't wrong. Kenpachi was telling Ichigo to protect his town (something Ichigo just tried to do in the last chapter) and to protect the girl (something Ichigo is trying to do NOW).  The way Ichigo phrased his "my duty is to protect my nakama" makes it sound like he made a choice whereas the fact is---the choice was already made for him because the exits from HM were sealed.

Just glory-hogging like your average shounen hero?

The line "to protect my nakama" didn't faze me at first glance. My shipper biases  were to note that Ichigo has yet to say he's come specifically to rescue Inoue-san in this entire arc (contrast Mister "I'm here to rescue Inoue-san, not to fight Espada" Ishida Uryuu) and that he didn't even call her by name in this scene. But beyond that, the line didn't bother me too much. Then brightredglow pointed out in her LJ that maybe Kubo " realized how bad Ichigo looked when he didn't think of Orihime in 313 so he put this lame dialogue in."

Do ya think?

I like to think better of my Kubo in that I believe Ichigo's not thinking right away of Orihime in 313 was natural, understandable ( and deliberate on the part of the author) and that the rest of Ichigo's behavior is in character. Still, I think people are onto something. Ichigo isn't sitting right with audiences. He seems off. He seems scattered and cocky and I think Kubo wants us to see him this way.

I think we're going to see an upset of the powers that be in Ichigo's inner world soon. I hope we see HOLLOW!ICHIGO.

Comments

[schweinsty.livejournal.com]

Whoah there - Ishida is naked? And I missed this?

Hmm, Re: Ichigo: I just saw that, went 'oh, eh, there he goes again,' and let it go. But in retrospect, I think it's a bit callous of him to just be all 'Forget about my town and family, let me go fight to save my friends! Rah!'

But, in retrospect, I think it is sort of typically Ichigo. Even in SS he tended to always be looking for fights - not to waste time, but just wanting to beat each and every person up the chain of command so he could free Rukia, and I think this is sort of an extension of that. Right now he's in HM, he's got Ulquiorra in front of him, and for them to find a way to get out of HM and keep all his friends safe, in Ichigo's mind beating Ulquiorra is a must. Also, I think there's a certain amount of trusting the shinigami captains to keep Karakura safe - at least until he can make it out of HM. And, besides that, he is 16 and spazzy.

Mostly, though, I'm excited about naked Ishida. =D.

[http://users.livejournal.com/_debbiechan_/]

You have a point there. Ichigo WAS looking for fights in SS, to the point that just wanted to fight with Ganjyu at the risk of avoiding his purpose of saving Rukia.

He was that "punk" even before Soul Society who needed no excuse to beat up on those guys who were beating up on Keigo. He beat up on people who knocked over the dead girl's flowers. He was just cruisin for a bruisin. This is Ichigo.

I thought he was growing up, though.

And where is Shirosaki in all this?

[schweinsty.livejournal.com]

Hmm, I think Shirosaki, in this last chapter, really didn't figure in at all. Ichigo was completely in control of himself in this chapter - but I think that, as soon as Ichigo starts fighting Ulquiorra in earnest (unless someone stops him), Shirosaki's going to take the chance to try to take control.